When it comes to real estate investing, everyone loves to talk about cash flow, appreciation, and the thrill of a deal. But at some point, you have to ask yourself: what’s the endgame? How are you going to turn that equity or profit on paper into something tangible? This is where the two most popular exit strategies come into play: selling the property outright or refinancing it. Both options have their perks and pitfalls, and today, we’re diving into the gritty details to help you decide which strategy might work best for you.

Let’s keep it real—you’ll probably hate one of these strategies by the end of this post, and that’s okay. I’m here to break it all down with a little dry humor, a dash of sarcasm, and plenty of practical advice. Let’s get to it.

The Great Sell-Off: Turning Your Property into Cold, Hard Cash

Selling your property is the go-to exit strategy most people are familiar with. It’s straightforward: you sell the asset, pocket the proceeds (or what’s left after the vultures—I mean, fees—take their cut), and move on. Sounds simple, right? Not so fast.

Pros of Selling

  1. Cash in Hand
    Let’s not downplay it—having a stack of cash feels good. Like, really good. Selling gives you immediate liquidity, which can be a game-changer if you’re looking to reinvest, pay off debt, or just buy a boat (no judgment).
  2. Hands-Off Freedom
    Sold your property? Congrats! You’re officially out of the landlord game for that asset. No more tenants calling about leaky faucets or raccoons in the attic.
  3. Portfolio Reset
    Selling can give you the chance to step back, reassess, and hunt for the next big deal—or not. Maybe you’re ready for a break. Either way, selling can clear the slate.

Cons of Selling

  1. Bye-Bye Passive Income
    That property might’ve been putting money in your pocket each month. Once you sell, that cash flow? Gone. And good luck finding another property that performs as well, especially in today’s market.
  2. Tax Penalties (Ouch)
    Selling opens you up to a lovely little thing called capital gains tax. If you haven’t planned ahead with tools like a 1031 exchange or invested in an Opportunity Zone, you could be handing over 20-30% of your profit to Uncle Sam. Fun times.
  3. Closing Costs and Commissions
    You’ll be paying everyone and their dog: title companies, attorneys, realtors. Expect closing costs to eat up 3-5% of your sale price, plus an additional 6% commission if you’re using a realtor. Oh, and don’t forget any liens, mortgages, or other expenses lurking in the shadows.
Sell or Refinance: Which Real Estate Exit Strategy is Right for You? I Leland Baptist I Blog

The Refinance Route: Leveraging What You’ve Built

Now, let’s talk about refinancing. This strategy is like giving your property a second wind. Instead of selling, you borrow against the equity and get cash out without losing ownership. Sounds fancy, but is it worth it?

Types of Refinancing

  1. Rate-and-Term Refinance
    This is the vanilla option. No cash changes hands; you’re simply adjusting your interest rate or loan terms to save money or stabilize your payments.
  2. Cash-Out Refinance
    This is where it gets interesting. With a cash-out refi, you’re essentially taking a loan against your property’s equity and walking away with some cash. The government considers it debt, not income, which means—wait for it—no immediate taxes.

Pros of Refinancing

  1. Tax Benefits
    Unlike selling, refinancing doesn’t trigger capital gains tax. In fact, the interest on your new loan might even be tax-deductible, giving you another sweet little write-off.
  2. Keep the Asset
    You still own the property, which means you can keep collecting rent, building equity, and enjoying appreciation. It’s like having your cake and eating it too.
  3. Lower Your Tax Liability
    High-income earners like doctors and lawyers often use refinancing to offset their tax burdens. By leveraging their properties, they can reduce taxable income while still getting access to cash.

Cons of Refinancing

  1. It’s Still Debt
    Let’s not sugarcoat it: you’re borrowing money. If you’re not careful, refinancing can backfire and leave you overleveraged.
  2. Costs Can Add Up
    Refinancing isn’t free. You’ll pay fees for appraisals, loan origination, and closing costs. These can range from 2-6% of the loan amount, so make sure the math works in your favor.
  3. No Instant Exit
    Unlike selling, refinancing doesn’t let you wash your hands of the property. You’re still responsible for managing it, dealing with tenants, and handling maintenance.

So, Which Strategy Wins?

The answer depends on your goals, your financial situation, and, frankly, how much stress you’re willing to tolerate.

Choose Selling If:

  • You need cash now and don’t mind losing the asset.
  • You’re ready to step away from real estate investing, either temporarily or permanently.
  • You’ve planned for the tax hit and can stomach the fees.

Choose Refinancing If:

  • You want to keep the property and continue building wealth over time.
  • You’re looking for tax advantages and a way to access cash without selling.
  • You have a long-term plan for managing the debt responsibly.

Final Thoughts

Real estate is all about strategy, and your exit plan is just as important as how you get into a deal. Whether you choose to sell or refinance, the key is to know your numbers. What will you actually walk away with after fees, taxes, and other costs?

And remember, no strategy is perfect. Selling might feel like ripping off a Band-Aid, while refinancing can feel like playing the long game. Either way, make sure the choice aligns with your overall financial goals.

As always, do your homework, talk to your CPA, and for the love of all things profitable, plan ahead. You don’t want to be that person scrambling for answers the day before closing.

See you on the next one—hopefully with fewer raccoons in your attic.

Similar Posts